J.W. LYNNE
AUTHOR OF BESTSELLING NOVELS WITH TWISTS, TURNS, AND SURPRISES
Connect with J.W. LYNNE on
 

How I won a Broadway ticket lottery ... twice

*Note: This article contains information about my experiences entering Broadway ticket lotteries in September and October 2019.

Whenever I'm in New York, I try to see a Broadway show ... or two ... or three. That can get expensive, so I always keep a look out for ways to find discounted tickets to the shows on my bucket list. A few years ago, I learned about the online Broadway ticket lotteries. These lotteries aren't a chance to win free tickets to Broadway shows. Instead, people enter to win the opportunity to purchase deeply-discounted last-minute tickets to top Broadway shows.

There are multiple sites that run online Broadway ticket lotteries, including Telecharge, Lucky Seat, Broadway Direct, and TodayTix. At the time of this writing, Telecharge runs the lotteries for Ain't Too Proud, Beautiful: The Carole King Musical, Beetlejuice, Come From Away, Dear Evan Hansen, Oklahoma, and The Phantom of the Opera. Aladdin, Hamilton, The Lion King, Wicked, and Tootsie are with Broadway Direct. The Book of Mormon, Frozen, Mean Girls, Hadestown, and Moulin Rogue! The Musical are with Lucky Seat. TodayTix runs the Friday Forty lottery ($40 tickets ($20 per part)) for Harry Potter and the Cursed Child (which is a play rather than a musical, but landed on my Harry Potter Bucket List). You can find up to date information on Playbill.com. They have a page that lists Broadway shows and their discount ticket policies. If there is a particular show you're interested in, you may want to check out their official website as well.


A portion of the playbill.com page that lists Broadway shows and their discount ticket policies.

In my story here on mydreamcametrue.com about what it's like to enter the Broadway ticket lotteries, you can read about how my mom and I entered the lotteries many times and never won. I had actually begun to think that it was downright impossible to win. But then something happened to change my thinking about the Broadway ticket lotteries ... I won ... TWICE.

It was September 2019, and I was visiting New York for an entire month. My mom and I planned to enter the Broadway ticket lotteries every day for Hadestown, Frozen, Hamilton, and Mean Girls. On the Friday before I arrived in New York, we entered the lotteries for the Sunday shows. As I expected, we lost. Undeterred, on Monday, we entered for the shows on Tuesday. At 11:23 AM on Monday morning, I heard the ping of a text message on my cellphone. I checked my phone and was shocked to see: "You won Lucky Seats to Frozen ... Check your email for details." (Note: Not all lotteries offer the option of receiving a text message if you win.) I couldn't believe it. I'd finally won a Broadway ticket lottery!

Bursting with happiness, I opened my email account and saw a message from Frozen Lottery. The subject: "You won the FROZEN ticket lottery!"


A portion of the email I received from Lucky Seat.

I clicked on the link in the email to purchase our tickets. The total purchase price for 2 tickets to Tuesday's show was $70 ($60.00 for the tickets plus a $10.00 service fee). There was no indication of which seats in the theater we would receive, but a quick look at the ticket availability for the Tuesday show on Ticketmaster.com revealed that there were still plenty of orchestra and mezzanine seats available, so we took a leap of faith. After I submitted my credit card information, I received an immediate email receipt from Lucky Seat Frozen. It informed us that our tickets would be waiting for us at the box office tomorrow evening.

On Tuesday evening, about an hour before showtime, Mom and I arrived at the St. James Theatre to claim our tickets. I presented my driver license to the woman at the box office, telling her that I was a lottery winner. She plucked a small stack of envelopes from her desk, opened one, and handed me the tickets inside. Our seats were in the Balcony, Row H, Seats 1 and 3. (A bit of research revealed that the cost of these seats for members of the general public on Ticketmaster.com (or at the box office) was $57.50 each.)

I decided to visit the Hadestown box office to purchase regularly-priced tickets to that show, since Hadestown was a must-see show for me, and I wanted to ensure that our seats would be very close to the stage. I considered continuing to enter the Hadestown lottery to try to win discount tickets, but I figured that our chances of winning that lottery was extremely low because the show was so popular.

At the Walter Kerr Theatre box office, I purchased two tickets for a matinee of Hadestown the following week. As I stepped away from the ticket window, two women approached it. "We're lottery winners," one of the women said to the woman behind the glass. After they retrieved their tickets for that evening's show, I asked them the general location of the their tickets. Their seats were not together, they told me. One was in a box and one in the mezzanine.

Mom and I continued to enter the lottery for Hamilton and Mean Girls, but we weren't having any luck. Early one Sunday morning, we decided on a whim to enter the lotteries for the Aladdin and The Lion King shows that day. It was the first time either of us had entered for either of these shows. Just after the lottery closed (at exactly 9AM that morning), I checked my email. I was shocked to see the subject on my email from Broadway Direct Lottery: "ALADDIN (NY) ... Lottery Results - YOU WON!"


A portion of the email I received from Broadway Direct.

The email contained all the details. The total purchase price for 2 tickets to that night's show was $66 ($60.00 for the tickets plus a $6.00 handling fee). I needed to claim my tickets no later than 10AM that day or they would be released. There was no indication of where in the theater the tickets would be. A quick check of the ticket availability on Ticketmaster showed excellent ticket availability for that night's show but, based on our experience with Frozen, I knew that ticket availability was no indication of what type of seats the lottery winners receive. I decided to take another leap of faith. I clicked the link to pay for our tickets and received a confirmation email.

That evening, we arrived at the New Amsterdam Theatre box office to pick up our tickets for Aladdin. When I presented my driver license to the man at the ticket window, he plucked an envelope from a small stack and handed me two tickets. The seats were in the Right Mezzanine, Row KK, Seats 14 and 16. (Checking online, I found that the cost of our seats for members of the general public on Ticketmaster.com or at the box office was $87.50 each.)

For the remainder of my month-long stay, we continued to enter the lotteries for Hamilton and Mean Girls every day, but we didn't win either of these lotteries.

I did, however, have a lucky moment, the luckiest of the entire trip ...

I wanted to see Waitress before it closed on Broadway (Waitress was scheduled to close in January 2020), and so this trip was my last chance. The show was not offering an online lottery. In the past, the show had offered $40 in-person rush tickets ("Rush tickets" are discounted same-day tickets offered to people who line up at the box office before it opens). When I checked online and on the show's official website for information on the show's current rush policy, I found no information. I decided to stop by the Brooks Atkinson Theatre to ask whether rush tickets were still offered.

The Waitress box office opened at 10AM, but I arrived at 11AM, a time when rush tickets are generally long gone. I asked the woman at the box office if they had a single rush ticket for that evening's show. I fully expected her to say no, or that the show no longer offers rush tickets. Instead, she said with a smile, "As a matter of fact, I do!" "Can you tell me where the seat is?" I asked. "Row C, seat 7, in the Orchestra," she replied pointing out the location on the theater map. I couldn't believe my eyes or ears. Excitedly, I purchased that rush ticket for $40 (there were no additional service or handling fees). Afterward, I learned that the regular price for this seat for members of the general public on Ticketmaster.com or at the box office was $159! (As I was leaving the Brooks Atkinson Theatre, another woman came to inquire about a single rush ticket for that night's performance. She was offered Orchestra Row M, seat 1.) I spent that Tuesday afternoon at the nearby Intrepid Museum, my heart swimming with delighted anticipation of the evening to come, feeling like I'd won the lottery!


The view from my rush seat for Waitress.

Will I be playing the Broadway ticket lotteries next time I’m in New York? I sure will!

I did this in September and October 2019.

~ Jen (California, USA)
 
ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Jen is also known as J.W. Lynne, a best selling author of twelve novels.
Check out her books on Amazon:

THE UNKNOWN: Eight kids learn the shocking reason why they were kidnapped.

ABOVE THE SKY: A girl lives in a world where touching her soulmate is forbidden.

WHAT HE DIDN'T TELL ME: A traumatized girl meets a boy with a horrible secret.

IF I TELL: A teen wonders if her father is a serial killer.

THE DARKNESS OUTSIDE
: A teen is locked in a bunker to take a simulated trip to the moon.

WILD ANIMAL SCHOOL: A girl falls in love with a boy at an exotic animal ranch.

KID DOCS: An experimental program turns kids into doctors.

**Not sure which book to choose? Visit our book recommendation page!**

**Jen's books are available on Kindle Unlimited.**

Besides reading books and dreaming up stories to write, Jen's favorite activities are singing along to musical theater soundtracks and hiking in California's beautiful parks.
 
 
What I learned about the Broadway ticket lotteries:

1. It is not impossible to win the Broadway ticket lotteries. Real people actually do win.

2. You can win Broadway ticket lotteries on the very first try (as I did for Aladdin).

3. It isn't easy to win the Broadway ticket lotteries. (My mom entered every lottery that I did and she lost every time.)

4. If you do win a Broadway ticket lottery, you may have to pay for your tickets without knowing your seat locations.
 
Do you have a recent Broadway (or Broadway tour) ticket lottery experience to share? Let me know the name of the show and how long you entered before you won (or how long you've been entering without winning). If you won tickets, also include the date of the performance and the location of your seats, and I'll share it here on mydreamcametrue.com.

Readers' Broadway ticket lottery experiences:


Aladdin WON:
"I won Aladdin tickets on my 3rd try on 12/11/2019. The Aladdin tickets cost $30 each with $6 handling fee. Our seats were in the middle of the first mezzanine." - Sully

Frozen WON:
"I entered for the first time on 1/13/2020 and won unclaimed tickets at the end of the day to Frozen. The next day I entered again, and I won tickets for the next night!" - Amy

Frozen WON:
"On 1/15/2020 I won tickets to Frozen! These tickets cost $42 each with $6 handling fee. We were completely floored when they kept telling us to walk down the aisle all the way to the first row of seats in Orchestra all the way on the right. We were amazed but also worried that our necks would hurt. Totally worth any neck stiffness! Elsa came running over in our direction and her dress grazed my face." - Sully

Hamilton WON:
"My mom's friend, who lives in New York, played the Hamilton Broadway ticket lottery almost every day for 2 years and 1 day, until she finally won. Her tickets were worth the wait: second row of the orchestra, on the aisle!"- Jen

Lion King WON:
"I won tickets to Lion King after a couple of weeks but wasn’t able to attend that evening." - Sully

Tootsie WON:
"I accidentally entered the lottery for Tootsie on Broadway for two tickets to a Tuesday night show in October 2019, and I won. I wasn't able to go."- Lois

Tootsie WON:
"I won tickets to Tootsie on 12/15/2019! These tickets cost $42 each with a $6 handling fee. We were so excited when we found out our tickets were on the left Orchestra maybe 7 rows back." - Sully


Broadway tour ticket lottery experiences:


LOS ANGELES:

Anastasia (Hollywood Pantages Theatre) LOST: "I entered the lotteries for one ticket to all six weekend matinee performances in October 2019, and I lost."- Jen

ST. LOUIS:

Hamilton (St. Louis) WON: "I entered the Ham app lottery a few times and was lucky enough to win tickets to the final show - Row A, just to the right of the center aisle! An amazing experience because it felt so personal to be that close to the stage. (These were $10 tickets.)"- Denise

Dear Evan Hansen (St. Louis) WON: "I entered the lottery for the first show of the run [Tuesday night in October 2019], and I received a "you weren't a winner" email. But, later that day, I got a text telling me some of the lottery tickets weren't claimed, so I got to go! (These tickets are $24 each plus a $1 service charge each.) Our seats were ok - middle balcony, just off center. I had a little trouble seeing all of the social media stuff on the set walls at this height, but that isn't completely necessary to enjoy the show. I won again on Tuesday [for Wednesday's show]! I only entered because I originally was told that I hadn't won the day before. I didn't pick up the 2nd winning tickets, however. I didn't want to go 2 consecutive days."- Denise

Do you have a recent Broadway (or Broadway tour) ticket lottery experience to share? Let me know the name of the show and how long you entered before you won (or how long you've been entering without winning). If you won tickets, also include the date of the performance and the location of your seats, and I'll share it here on mydreamcametrue.com.
 
Broadway theater ticket tips:

1. If you MUST see a particular show, buy your tickets in advance. To purchase tickets, visit the show's official website. The official website will likely send you to Ticketmaster or Telecharge to actually purchase the tickets. You can also buy tickets in-person at the theater's box office.

2. Sometimes there are discounts available for advance-purchase tickets. Here at mydreamcametrue.com, we’ve had success with finding discount codes at broadwaybox.com. Grab these coupon codes and enter them on the Telecharge or Ticketmaster website to receive an instant savings. Note that promo codes are not available for all shows.

3. You can try your luck at scoring discounted, same-day “rush” tickets by heading to the theater before the box office opens. Playbill.com lists the "rush ticket" policies for current shows. You can also find information about rush tickets on the individual show's official website. Not all shows offer rush tickets. Note that if you aren’t one of the first few people in line when the box office opens, you may not get tickets. People queue up in the early hours of the morning for some shows. Even though people generally line up for rush tickets long before the box office opens, it doesn't hurt to ask if you arrive later, especially if you only need one ticket.

4. If today's performance is sold out, you can try your luck at scoring same-day standing-room-only tickets (SRO tickets) by heading to the theater before the box office opens. Playbill.com lists the "standing-room-only ticket" policies for current shows. Not all shows offer standing-room-only tickets, and these tickets are only offered for sold-out performances. You must be willing to stand in the back of the orchestra for the entire performance. Note that if you aren’t one of the first few people in line when the box office opens, you may not get tickets. People queue up in the early hours of the morning for some shows.

5. If you're still looking for same-day tickets and it’s just hours before showtime, head to one of the Theater Development Fund’s same-day ticket booths (TKTS). In the past, I’ve visited the Time Square TKTS booth and found fifty-percent-off deals on great orchestra and mezzanine seats. When the booths are open, Theater Development Fund’s official website lists available shows, discount percentages, and live prices. You cannot buy these tickets online or over the phone. If they have tickets for a show you want to see, go to one of their booths and buy your tickets in person. Note that discount tickets are not available for all shows.

**Shows all over the world (including in Appleton, Baltimore, Boston, Chicago, Ft. Lauderdale, London, Los Angeles, Madison, Memphis, Milwaukee, Minneapolis, Philadelphia, San Francisco, St. Louis, Tulsa, and Woodinville) sometimes offer online ticket lotteries. If you want to see a local show at a deeply-discounted bargain price, check out Lucky Seat, the show's official website, or the venue's official website to see if there is a lottery offered.